THE ABILITY TO ROB DEAD BODIES/ENFORCE FEAR RP
have now attempted to rob three separate players, all of whom have failed to follow Fear RP and outright refused to put their hands up. I genuinely don't see the point of enforcing Fear RP as a server rule if there is no mechanism in place to support it.
This completely undermines the interaction and ruins the roleplay experience for the robbers, while effectively rewarding the player who is breaking the rules. There is little incentive to comply with Fear RP when refusing to cooperate carries no immediate consequences.
Furthermore, all three individuals appeared to be established, experienced players. This suggests the issue isn't isolated to newcomers or trolls, but extends to players who should already understand and respect the server's rules.
Ultimately, I believe there needs to be a mechanism that allows robberies to function as intended, rather than leaving the outcome entirely dependent on whether the victim chooses to follow the rules.
Log in to comment and vote
Comments7
lynked
Oct 31
Whitelisted gang members can already rob the dead bodies of other WL members.
If you’ve robbed three (3) people, I’m genuinely hoping you have a good & valid reason for every single one of them.
I genuinely don't see the point of enforcing Fear RP as a server rule if there is no mechanism in place to support it.The support is you clipping and reporting it then allowing us to deal with it, just because you’re not able to get their items doesn’t mean there’s no “support” for it.There is little incentive to comply with Fear RP when refusing to cooperate carries no immediate consequences.The immediate consequence is they’re dealt with for not valuing their life, simple as that.i_love_being_awake
Oct 31
I understand that clipping and reporting players is an available form of enforcement, and I appreciate that staff take those reports seriously. However, my point is that administrative action after the fact doesn't resolve the issue within the RP interaction itself. By the time a report is reviewed, the interaction has already been disrupted, and the opportunity for meaningful RP has been lost.
I'm not suggesting that players should be able to rob anyone without justification, nor am I questioning the enforcement of existing rules. I'm simply suggesting a mechanic that would complement those rules and encourage players to comply in the moment, rather than relying entirely on reports afterward.
I also think it's important to acknowledge the disparity between the consequences of losing your inventory and losing your life. In a realistic RP scenario, someone facing a credible threat to their life would generally prioritize their survival over their possessions. However, the players I've encountered seem to approach these situations purely from a gameplay perspective, knowing that dying and getting revived is often preferable to surrendering their inventory.
And that's really the underlying issue. When the immediate consequence of refusing to comply is a few minutes spent waiting for a revival, while surrendering could mean losing items that took hours to obtain, the game effectively incentivizes players to disregard Fear RP. Even if administrative consequences follow later, they don't necessarily discourage that decision in the moment, particularly when players believe they can get away with it.
Ultimately, I don't see this as something that exclusively benefits criminals or those conducting robberies. It's about ensuring that the mechanics of the server reinforce the RP standards we're all expected to follow. If valuing your life is one of the fundamental rules of the server, I think the gameplay should reflect that principle rather than inadvertently incentivizing players to disregard it.
I believe a proper surrender mechanic would help address this imbalance, complement existing enforcement, and improve the overall quality and consistency of RP for everyone involved.
lynked
Oct 31
Since I’m speaking to an AI, I’ll reply the same!
I understand the distinction you’re making between staff enforcement afterward and a mechanic that supports the interaction in the moment. I agree that having an interaction ruined isn’t undone by a report being handled later.
However, choosing to disregard Fear RP because keeping your inventory is more convenient is still a player choosing to break the rules. The expectation to value your life applies regardless of how valuable your items are or how quickly you think you’ll be revived. Believing you can get away with it doesn’t change that expectation.
A surrender mechanic is something we can discuss, but we also have to consider how it could be abused and whether it would encourage people to shoot someone and loot them instead of continuing the interaction. WL gang members already have the ability to rob other WL members’ bodies, so expanding access needs more consideration than simply making refusal less appealing.
Your point about mechanics reinforcing RP is fair. Where I disagree is the idea that Fear RP has little purpose without this mechanic. Mechanics can support the standard, but players are still responsible for meeting it. Any proposed change needs to improve the RP on both sides, with clear limits and valid justification for the robbery.
i_love_being_awake
Oct 31
I think we're actually agreeing on quite a bit here. I'm not arguing that players are justified in breaking Fear RP because keeping their inventory is more convenient. I'm saying that the current mechanics make breaking that rule more appealing than following it, which is exactly the problem I'm trying to address.
I also agree that a surrender mechanic would need safeguards to prevent abuse, but I don't see that as a reason not to consider one. The rules surrounding legitimate robberies would still apply, and anyone abusing the mechanic should be held accountable just as they would be now.
My point has never been that Fear RP is meaningless without a surrender mechanic, but that there's a difference between punishing someone for breaking a rule and having systems in place that encourage them to follow it in the first place. Ideally, we should have both.
I'm glad we can agree that mechanics should reinforce RP. That's really all I'm advocating for here.
lesterx207
Oct 31
also one of the main servers rules is dont just be robbing player for no reason… do you have a viable reason and role play leading up to said 3 attempted robberies
adrianjames
Oct 31
One of the main rules in server is to value your life. If they are not putting hands up, grab IDs and send clip in. They’ll be taken care of guaranteed.
i_love_being_awake
Oct 31
I agree, and I understand that reporting them is an option. My point is that having to resort to a report doesn't resolve the issue in the moment. The interaction is already ruined, and the person breaking Fear RP has effectively dictated the outcome. I'd much rather see a mechanism that prevents this from happening in the first place.